Recently, various wavelength-sized 1D, 2D or 3D cavities with theoretical Q of $10^5$ and ultra small modal volume V of 0.04 $(\lambda/2n)^3$ have been reported, however in most of these cavities air is used as low dielectric material ($\lambda$ is the wavelength, and n is the refractive index). Here we implement three-dimensional finite-difference time-domain simulations to investigate physical phenomena in more detail and demonstrate that it is possible to achieve a high Q over V ratio by employing 1D periodicity and various types of materials as low dielectric material.
There are two different methods to store photons for longer than one nanosecond in a wavelength-sized volume. One way is to rely on total internal reflection (ring or disc resonators), and the second is to employ strong light confinement of a photonic band gap in a well-designed structure [1, 2]. A combination of, these effects may also be employed, e.g. use of a photonic band gap in one dimension and total internal reflection in the other two dimensions. Total internal reflection only holds for a certain restricted range of wave vectors, and thus it becomes ineffective when the cavity size becomes small because localization in real space leads to delocalization in k-space, which eventually breaks the total internal reflection condition. Photonic band gap confinement works regardless of the wave vector range, and thus it is essentially better for confining light in a small volume than total internal reflection.
A modification of the original bowtie structure [3] is suggested in Fig. 1. Here we use different low dielectric material and buried channel [4] instead of a slit that goes all the way through the structure in the z direction. To excite our cavity we use an Ey field. However, because of the scattering element in the center of the structure (in this case a channel), other E field components appear (Ex and Ez). These two additional E field elements are not confined in the structure and are radiated away. Therefore, Ex and Ez components in the center of a cavity are very small compared to the Ey field.

In conclusion high Q and low V structures were simulated. Different designs of photonic crystal micro cavities were investigated and it was shown in more details that it is possible to get low modal volume by introducing a channel or a slit in the center of the micro cavity which however in turn causes delocalization in k-vector space and a low quality factor. It was demonstrated that a channel is better than a slit because of guiding by total internal reflection in the z direction. In addition to this, it was shown that cavities which have silicon dioxide as the low dielectric material are worse compared to cavities with air because of reduced total internal reflection. This drawback, however, has to be taken into account when considering devices with cladding instead of air bridges, because the latter are not useful for integrated devices.