MEASUREMENT CAPABILITIES OF 14C USING THE TRIPLE-TO-DOUBLE COINCIDENCE RATIO METHOD

Paulius Butkus1, Arūnas Gudelis2

1 Faculty of Physics, Vilnius University, Saulėtekio Ave. 9-III, LT-10222 Vilnius, Lithuania

2 Center for Physical Sciences and Technology, Institute of Physics, Ionizing Radiation Metrology Laboratory, Savanorių Ave. 231, LT-02300, Vilnius, Lithuania

The triple-to-double coincidence ratio (TDCR) method is a primary standardization method in liquid scintillation counting with three-photomultiplier tubes (PMT) developed for the absolute activity measurement of pure beta minus and electron capture emitters in solution. It is a direct method, although the decay scheme data for a given radionuclide are necessary for the detection efficiency calculation. The method itself is based on a physical and statistical model of the distribution of scintillation photons and their detection probability in a three-photomultiplier counter. The non-linearity of the scintillator response due to the ionization-quenching phenomenon is also taken into account.[1] The software TDCRB-02 available from the ICRM LSC working group web site was used for the specific activity determination.

In previous work low-level samples containing known amounts of 36Cl, 63Ni and 90Sr were prepared and measured with the TDCR device. The specific activities were determined with the help of the software TDCRB-02 and compared with known values. It was found that the divergence from the expected value for 36Cl, 63Ni and 90Sr was 0.9 %, 2.7 % and 1.7%, respectively, within the specified uncertainty limits. Results suggested the suitability of the TDCR techniques for low-level counting. As an application for measurement of low energy beta-radiation, further investigations on the assessment of the measurement capabilities of the TDCR instrument for pure beta-emitters 3H and 14C at varying activity levels were planned. [2]

The aim of this study was to apply the TDCR method for the activity measurement of unquenched samples with pure beta-emitter 14C and determine the best conditions in which the discrepancy from the “true value” is the lowest. For this purpose different samples of beta-emitter 14C in different conditions were measured with the TDCR instrument.

The first sample with 14C was prepared in a polyethylene counting vial from the working solution by mixing 0.15 mL of it with 16 mL of the Ultima Gold LLT scintillator. The blank sample containing 16 mL of the same type of a scintillator was used for the background correction. Five repeat measurements of 600 s each were carried out for all samples at three fixed high voltage values set to the PMTs for varying the detection efficiency of the LS-detector. It was found that the divergence from the expected value was 2.59 %. To reduce the divergence a new approach of measurement was investigated. This time, six repeat measurements of 60 s each were carried out for all samples at six fixed high voltage values set to the PMTs. The final absolute activity was taken as a mean value of all measurements activities at this condition. It was found that the divergence from the expected value was 7.46%. In this case the discrepancy was unacceptable and it was decided to prosecute an inquiry. A new sample with 14C was prepared in a 16 mL glass vial and measured at the same conditions as previously. It was found that for 14C the discrepancy was 1.59 %, within the specified uncertainty limits. Results of the standardization of 14C with the TDCR device and the use of the TDCRB-02 software are summarized in Table 1.

Table 1. Results of standardization of 14C with the TDCR device
Specific activity (kBq g-1)
Calculated from the certificateDetermined from experimentRelative discrepancy (%)
$40.01 \pm 0.60$$41.048 \pm 1.207$+2.59
$39.81 \pm 0.60$$42.997 \pm 1.620$+2.7
$39.93 \pm 0.60$$39.305 \pm 0.074$-1.59

All results show that the TDCR primary standardization method gives a potential to measure activity of 14C with high accuracy. However, divergence from the expected values is still unacceptable and further investigations must be taken to improve the accuracy.


[1] R. Broda, A review of the triple-to-double coincidence ratio (TDCR) method for standardizing radionuclides, Applied Radiation and Isotopes 58 (2003) 585-594

[2] A. Gudelis, A. Vinčiūnas, P. Butkus, M. Pranaitis, Measurements of some radionuclides using a new TDCR system and an ultra low-level conventional LSC counter in CPST, Lithuania, Applied Radiation and Isotopes, DOI: 10.1016/j.apradiso.2012.02.091