QUANTUM CHEMISTRY IN THE SERVICE OF MODERN CRYSTALLOGRAPHY – TESTING NEW REFINEMENT METHODS ON A SET OF CRYSTAL STRUCTURES OF AMINO ACIDS AND TRIPEPTIDES

Magdalena Woińska1, Simon Grabowsky2, Dylan Jayatilaka3, Paulina Dominiak1, Krzysztof Woźniak1

1 Biological and Chemical Research Centre, Chemistry Department, University of Warsaw, Żwirki i Wigury 101, 02-089 Warsaw, Poland

2 Institut für Anorganische Chemie und Kristallographie, Fachbereich 2 - Biologie/Chemie, Universität Bremen, Leobener Str. NW2, 28359 Bremen, Germany

3 School of Chemistry and Biochemistry, The University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Highway, Perth WA 6009, Australia

X-ray diffraction is the most commonly applied experimental method of investigating structure of substances in the crystal phase. Moreover, high resolution crystallographic measurements allow to reconstruct electron density which is a rich source of information about properties of molecules in crystals and interactions between them. However, extracting reliable information requires not only good quality experimental data, but also advanced data processing methods (i.e. crystallographic refinement methods) based on sophisticated models utilizing the achievements of quantum chemistry. To date, the most popular technique is the multipole refinement (MM) introduced by Hansen and Coppens [1], which, due to insufficient flexibility and not constraining the refined electron density to any physical quantity, is known to yield experimental density characterized by many flaws [2]. Alternative methods presented in this work are two refinement techniques, such as Hirshfeld atom refinement (HAR, refinement of positional parameters of atoms only) and the subsequent fitting of experimentally constrained wave function (XCW, introducing the experimental contribution to the wave function) [3][4], based on Hirshfeld partition of electron density. In this partition each atom in the crystal is ascribed its own contribution to the molecular density, which is proportional to its share in the density of a molecule constructed of spherically averaged atomic densities. On the basis of this procedure the parameters necessary to carry out refinement of crystal structure and electron density are obtained. HAR and XCW use extensively computational chemistry methods, as each refinement step includes ab initio calculations of the molecular wave function. For these techniques, the obtained electron density is constrained to the quantum mechanical minimum of energy, unlike for MM. HAR and XCW are therefore free from serious limitations of MM, which for example results in significant improvement of the description of positions and thermal motions of hydrogen atoms in crystals [4].

In this contribution we would like to present the comparison of the described methods of high resolution X-ray data refinement for a set of crystalline structures of 4 amino acids and 6 tripeptides. The quality of electron density in crystals reconstructed with the applied techniques is evaluated basing on the analysis performed within QTAIM formalism [5]. This method allows to partition the space in the crystal into separate fragments belonging to each atom and thus obtain atomic properties such as charge, dipole moment and volume, as well as properties at the bond critical points (BCPs, critical points of electron density present in the vicinity of chemical bonds) such as electron density or its Laplacian. QTAIM properties obtained with MM, HAR and XCW on the basis of the experimental electron density are compared to the benchmark values derived from periodic DFT calculations carried out for all the structures with CRYSTAL06 program. The analysis of bond lengths and thermal motions of atoms in the investigated crystals is also performed. The selected compounds allow to study certain types of C, N, O and H atoms and bonds linking them, which are common not only in molecules of biological importance but also in a variety of organic compounds. Therefore, the analysis of trends revealed by QTAIM properties in the chosen class of compounds facilitates drawing more general conclusions concerning the performance of each of the refinement methods. Our study reveals the advantage of the Hirshfeld partition based methods over MM in the description of electron density in crystals derived from X-ray experiments. MM systematically underestimates atomic charges of N, O and C and also tends to incorrectly describe polar bonds such as C-N or C-O, overestimating electron density and Laplacian at the BCPs and resulting in wrong description of the regions of O lone electron pairs. HAR and XCW eliminate these problems, moreover they yield QTAIM properties being in significantly higher agreement with the theoretical values and also result in better quality of the refined structures compared to MM. It is worth noting that including experimental contribution to the molecular wave function by XCW causes certain divergence from the reference values, thereby making HAR the method best reproducing the results of theoretical calculations.


[1] N. K. Hansen & P. Coppens, Testing aspherical atom refinements on small-molecule data sets, Acta Cryst. A34, 909-921 (1978).

[2] J. M. Bąk, S. Domagała, C. Hübschle, C. Jelsch, B. Dittrich & P. M. Dominiak, Verification of structural and electrostatic properties obtained by the use of different pseudoatom databases, Acta Cryst. A67, 141-153 (2011).

[3] D. Jayatilaka & B. Dittrich, Acta Cryst. A64, 383-393 (2008).

[4] S. C. Capelli, H.-B. Bürgi, B. Dittrich, S. Grabowsky & D. Jayatilaka, IUCrJ, 1, 361-379 (2014).

[5] R. F. W. Bader, Atoms in Molecules: A Quantum Theory, 1st ed. No. 22 in the International Series of Monographs on Chemistry. Oxford: Clarendon Press (1990).