COMPARISON OF NON-RELATIVISTIC AND QUASIRELATIVISTIC APPROACHES IN THE CASE OF IRON IONS

Darius Stonys1, Pavel Bogdanovich1

1 Institute of Theoretical Physics and Astronomy, Vilnius University, Lithuania

Over many years in the Department of the Theory of an Atom at ITPA VU, broad theoretical research of atom and ion spectral parameters has been conducted. In order to calculate these spectral characteristics, two approaches that differ by their radial orbitals (RO) are most often used. By solving the Hartree-Fock equations (HFE) [2,3] in the case of non-relativistic approach (NRA), we determine the RO that describe investigated atom configurations. Similarly, in the case of quasirelativistic approach (QRA), we acquire the RO by solving the quasirelativistic HFE. In both these approaches the relativistic effects are taken into account by defining the Hamiltonian matrix in the framework of the Breit-Pauli approximation. We account for the correlation corrections by the configuration interaction (CI) method. For this reason we construct a broad base of transformed radial orbitals (TRO) [4] that guarantee the maximal energy correlation corrections. Afterwards TRO are applied to generate an extensive list of all possible admixed configurations, so we adopt a small variable parameter $w$ as a criterion to select only those admixed configurations that make the greatest contribution to the adjusted configuration (AC) wavefunction. Finally, this selected configuration base is employed to calculate AC energy level spectra, radiative transition parameters and electron collision data.

Although both methods under consideration have been used for a long time, no research has been performed to compare their effectiveness. There is only one publication [5] in which the convergence of QRA with the variation of the selection parameter $w$ is analyzed.

In this work we examine and compare the dependence on $w$ of various physical characteristics, calculated in NRA and QRA in the case of the iron ions (Fe10+, Fe12+, Fe18+ and Fe20+). We have selected these ions because of available experimental data [6] and the suitability of NRA, since their ionization degree is not too high.

One of the most reliable indicators that verify the accuracy of CI calculations is a correspondence between experimental data and theoretical results. To evaluate the discrepancy between theory and experiment we use the mean square deviation $σ$. We present some deviations from experiment [6] of NRA and QRA with different $w$ values in Table 1.

Table 1. The mean square deviations $σ$ of the Fe ion energy spectra (in cm-1) with selection parameters $w$ in bold.
w
IonMethod110-410-510-610-710-8
NRA43951326715700706701
Fe10+QRA4289591622495502500
NRA1195536182194231422552262
Fe12+QRA1169740391858166716041594
NRA17981117021119210402101109961
Fe18+QRA11891639712075608760026000
NRA422492072120586197581967119638
Fe20+QRA174421432415124141231392913776

The dependence on $w$ was evaluated for various characteristics: the size of configuration bases, computation times, spectral parameters (radiative lifetimes, transition probabilities) and etc. Furthermore, we also examined the dependence of theoretical level energies accuracy on the size of CI base and on the number of active AC shells.

It is evident from Table 1 that both approaches fluctuate while converging, however, QRA converges to a smaller deviation value compared to NRA deviation. Consequently, QRA facilitates calculation of more accurate results than NRA while using the same computer resources.


[1] V. Fock, Näherungsmethods zur Lösung des quantenmechanischen Mehrkörperproblems, Zr. für Phys., B. 61, 126 (1930).

[2] P. Bogdanovich, O. Rancova, Quasi-relativistic Hartree-Fock equations consistent with Breit-Pauli approach, Phys. Rev. A, 74, 052501 (2006).

[3] P. Bogdanovich, O. Rancova, Adjustment of the quasirelativistic equations for p-electrons, Phys. Rev. A, 76, 012507 (2007).

[4] P. Bogdanovich, R. Karpuškienė, Transformed radial orbitals with a variable parameter for the configuration interaction, Lith. J. Phys 39, 193 (1999).

[5] P. Bogdanovich, D. Majus, T. Pakhomova, Investigation of accuracy of configuration interaction for oxygen isoelectronic sequence, Phys. Scripta, 74, 558 (2006).

[6] A. Kramida, Yu. Ralchenko, J. Reader and NIST ASD Team (2014). NIST Atomic Spectra Database (ver. 5.2), [Online]. Available: http://physics.nist.gov/asd [2015, February 5]. National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD.