Electroporation (EP) exploits short electrical pulses to controllably elevate cell plasma membrane permittivity to exogenous and endogenous molecules [1]. Control of the process, low joule heating and simplicity of the method resulted in electroporation to be widely implied in food processing, pasteurization, biotechnology and medicine. Such broad application of electroporation requires constant research to improve design and material composition for electroporation chambers or electrodes in order to make the process as reliable and cost efficient as possible. Many of electrode compositions as aluminum, copper, stainless steel, gold, platinum either carbon was investigated, where literature of the use of titanium electrodes for electroporation is scarce [2; 3]. The golden standard electrodes for electroporation are made of stainless steel. Electrodes of other alloys and materials are less popular mainly due to remarkably high metal ion release (i.e. aluminum, copper) or high material price (gold, platinum, carbon fibers). However, the most substantial criteria for proper electrodes is inertia longer lasting of the electrodes and reduces contamination of the sample material with metal ions. During our investigation we intended to evaluate whether the use of titanium electrodes for electroporation would substantially improve viability of electroporated cells without sacrificing the efficiency of electrotransfer of extracellular molecules into the cells.
Experiments were performed using Chinese hamster ovarian (CHO) cells. We used stainless steel (AISI 304: 18.1% chromium, 8.3% nickel) and titanium (BT-20: 5.5-7% aluminum, 0.5-2% molybdenum, 0.8-2.5% vanadium, 1.5-2.5% zirconium) electrodes separated by 2 mm gap for placement of the cells. Cells were electroporated in low conductivity electroporation medium (0.1 S/m, 270 mOsmol, 7.2 pH) in order to reduce current but maintain pH and osmolality. Cells were treated with 1 or 9 high voltage (HV) pulses of 100 μs duration repeating at 1 Hz frequency while pulse intensity was gradually changed from 0.6 kV/cm to 2.2 kV/cm. Cell electropermeabilization efficiency and level of irreversibly permeabilized cells was assessed by measuring intracellular Propidium iodide (PI) fluorescence intensity and number of PI positive cells (PI+) by flow cytometry. Viability of cells was determined using MTS assay 24 and 48 hours after treatment and colony formation assay (CFA) 6 days post treatment.
The results revealed that electrotransfer of extracellular PI into cells was identical comparing stainless steel vs titanium electrodes, where the number of PI+ cells and fluorescence intensity of the cells increased with amplification of electric field intensity. Interestingly, cell viability results demonstrated that cell viability of the cells electroporated between stainless steel or titanium electrodes remained similar under all conditions except 1.8 kV/cm 1 HV (55±4 % vs 31±12 % stainless steel vs titan) and 0.8 kV/cm 9HV (43±25 % vs 25±10 % stainless steel vs titan) when assayed with MTS 48 h after EP. After measuring the amount of irreversibly permeabilized cells we determined that the impact of titan electrodes on cell viability was not related to pore resealing. Results showed that a part of electroporated cells were electroporated irreversibly under all conditions, but this measure did not exceed 30 % of cells per sample.
Summing everything up, the use of titanium electrodes had nearly the same impact on cell membrane permeabilization and pore resealing after electroporation compared to stainless steel electrodes, while at particular pulse parameters cell viability was lower using titan electrodes. However, this effect was not related to pore resealing. In conclusion, the choice for which electrodes to use for cell electroporation remain solely under user's decision while titanium electrodes demonstrated nearly the same outcome of electroporated cells.