INTERMOLECULAR STRUCTURE AND NMR PARAMETERS IN BINARY MIXTURES OF TRIFLUORACETIC ACID AND N, N–DIMETHYLFORMAMIDE MODELLED BY QM/MD APPROACHES

Greta Majauskaitė1, Kęstutis Aidas1

1 Institute of Chemical Physics, Faculty of Physics, Vilnius University, Lithuania

Carboxylic acids are strongly associating compounds, whose intermolecular structures can vary from cyclic dimers to chain-type associates [1]. These complexes exist in a dynamic equilibrium that is characteristic of each specific acid. Leonardo W. Reeves' study focused on the formation of hydrogen bonds in modified acetic acids and their mixtures with different polar solvents and revealed a strong dependence of some NMR parameters on the molar composition of the mixture [2]. It has been observed that the difference between the chemical shift of the acidic proton of trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) in pure liquid and the mixture with N, N-dimethylformamide (DMF) is as high as 4 ppm. In contrast, the chemical shift of the acidic proton of pure acetic acid is virtually insensitive to the amount of DMF in the mixture. The reason for this difference can be due to changes at the molecular level when the hydrogens of the methyl group of the acetic acid are replaced by fluorines. This substitution can affect the dynamical equilibrium between molecular aggregates in pure acid and its mixture with DMF. Also, DMF is a good proton acceptor, which can lead to the formation of hydrogen bond aggregates between TFA and DMF molecules. Changing equilibrium between various intermolecular aggregates induced by changing the composition of the mixture could lead to such a drastic increase in chemical shift.

This study aims to identify which of the occurring changes in the intermolecular structure of trifluoracetic acid and its mixture with N, N – dimethylformamide led to this strong increase in chemical shift of the acidic proton between neat TFA and the TFA-DMF mixture with the molar ratio of 1:1.

To achieve this goal further computational scheme was implemented. MD simulations were carried out for both systems using an OPLS-AA force field. NPT ensemble was used to reach thermodynamic equilibrium and stable density of the system at the temperature of 298 K and pressure of 1 atm. The production run was performed in the NVT ensemble at the same temperature for 2 ns. After that, intermolecular structure analysis was performed using the geometrical definition of a hydrogen bond. This was followed by quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics calculations of the 1H NMR shielding constant of the acidic proton for both systems.

Our results show that by far the dominating form of intermolecular aggregates in neat TFA was that of the cyclic type – 60% overall, and especially cyclic trimers the population of which was as high as 48.5% on average. Interestingly, this constitutes a major qualitative difference compared to neat acetic acid, which is mainly composed of linear type chain aggregates, and even the cyclic structures that are formed are mostly dimers [3]. Moreover, our calculations revealed that the intermolecular structure of the TFA-DMF mixture changes drastically. All TFA molecular aggregates between TFA molecules are virtually broken, and instead, hydrogen-bonded TFA-DMF complexes are forming. The NMR shielding constants calculated for the acidic proton in neat TFA and the TFA-DMF mixture were computed to be equal to 21.64 (±0.12) and 20.26 (±0.12) ppm, respectively, was predicting that chemical shift of the acidic proton is by around 1.4 ppm in the TFA-DMF mixture than in the neat TFA. The predicted difference of the chemical shifts is considerably underestimated as compared to the corresponding experimental result. This discrepancy is likely caused due to the prolific proton transfer between TFA and DMF molecules in the mixture – an effect that was not accounted for in our model.

Acknowledgments: Computations were performed on the computational facilities provided by the High-Performance Computing Center "HPC Saulėtekis" at Vilnius University, Lithuania.


[1] Wu, J., 2014. Gaussian analysis of Raman spectroscopy of acetic acid reveals a significant amount of monomers that effectively cooperate with hydrogen bonded linear chains. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 16(41), pp.22458-22461.

[2] Reeves, L., 1961. Hydrogen bonding in solutions of substituted acetic acids. Can, Journ. of Chem, 39(8), pp. 1711–1720.

[3] D. Lengvinaite, K. Aidas, L. Kimtys, 2019. Molecular aggregation in liquid acetic acid: Insight from molecular dynamics/quantum mechanics modeling of structural and NMR properties, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 21, pp.14811–14820. https://doi.org/10.1039/c9cp01892a.